Thoughts on Zionism

Random thoughts on Zionism (ok not random they were points missing in someone else’s overview of Zionism but they will be random to you):

– traditionally Jewish politics put God in the position of sovereign and the nation of Israel in the position of contingent steward/tenant; Zionism is about autonomy, not sovereignty (and for many supporters of Israel, the real fear is a loss of that autonomy)

– Zionist branding worked because the national aspiration for a holy and just society, and the cultural meaning of Zion, already existed in the biblical literature and liturgy for thousands of years

– modern political Zionism starts with Doña Gracia Nasi’s organized purchases of land in the 16th century for the express purpose of re-establishing Jewish settlement in Israel and points to the direct connection between Jewish disenfranchisement as a diasporic minority and the need for Jewish landed autonomy

– religious Zionism may be redundant but insofar as it’s a valid label it can be used to describe many Zionist groups in the 19th and 20th century, and such Zionist leaders as R Abraham Isaac Kook z”l without mention of whom no discussion of religious Zionism can be complete

Benevolent Sensitivity

Jewish Religion: A Rough Sketch

At the heart of our practices, theories, and forms lies חסידות, a word translated variously as piety, loving-kindness, and mysticism.

For reasons that I hope will become clear, I prefer the somewhat clunky translation “benevolent sensitivity.”

The first usage of חסיד in the Torah is in Moshe rabbenu’s blessing of the tribe of Lewi: “Your tummim and urim [priestly oracle] to your Hassid” – a reference to the tribe’s general role, and the specific responsibility of the descendants of Aharon haKohen, in the guidance of Jewish religion, both in the central nexus of the Qodesh (al Quds) and scattered throughout the cities and communities of the nation.

Moshe was the rabban of all nebiim but we see that traditions, praxis, and concepts were transmitted, developed, and shared in the context of the Levitic activity, especially at the Qodesh. Ruwwah haQodesh – the psycho-spiritual experiential mode associated with this activity – was established as the preliminary to full nebua. From these circles emerged many of the nebiim that contributed to our textual and spiritual heritage.

But why Hassid?

I believe that the path of Israelite religion, as actively taught and developed by the nebiim especially of the tribe of Lewi, is one of cultivation of benevolent sensitivity, to one’s self – one’s nature and needs, to one’s fellows – their natures and needs, and to one’s God – and the nature and needs of the divine pathos, as R Heschel z”l described it, within the creation.

This path of cultivation brings the human being from raw animalistic potential to actualized psycho-spiritual resonance with the divine. It is the revelation and the attunement of the divine image in which all human beings were created, and it is the generative process that lies at the heart of all religions, including Islam, in the context of which it is called التصوف‎ the tasawwuf, Sufism.

Rambam, the last and greatest of the Geonim, drew upon the Sufi discourse and works of his Mediterranean milieu in formulating his exploration of nebua in his famous Guide. It may be justly said that the entire project of the Guide is the cultivation of a cognitive and intellectual sensitivity to the divine as an active alternative to the barren and often irrational quagmire of theology.

Rambam’s son, R Abraham Maimuni, overtly recognized the Islamic Sufis as contemporary adherents to the same Way of the ancient nebiim and publicly taught a form of practice that harmonized with theirs. Subsequent generations of the Maimuni family developed the Sufi themes of
Maimonideanism, both in writing and in practice, all with the aim of cultivating the self along the way of the nabi, as described above.

While the Maimuni Sufism did not directly survive the vicissitudes of history in a region ravaged by competing empires, it later contributed (along with the broader Sufi influence) to the development of the kabbalistic circles around the Mediterranean, which in turn resulted in the emergence of European Hassidism. And of course Rambam’s legacy, in the widespread impact of both his Guide and his legal rulings, definitively shaped the חסידות that came after him, both in illumination and in shadow.

It is only natural that Religionists – Sufis of whatever community – should work together to heal a world in desperate need of Religion, of “benevolent sensitivity.”

It is my hope that on this festival of Sukkoth, in which we continue the theme of unity with creation in worship of our Creator with an expansive hope for all the world’s families to join us in celebration of our Creator’s goodness, we will merit to traverse the bridges our ancestors and prophets built before us and between us, and bring the world to a more perfected state both in justice and in awareness of the divine.

PSA on Palestine

PSA to both Leftists and Right-Wingers:

If all you know about the situation in Palestine is derived from memes and viral posts, and you haven’t done any research into the history of this land, or learned about the peoples who come from it, or even just talked to both Palestinians and Israelis who have lived here for generations – then the most responsible and helpful thing you can do for us is to support BOTH Palestinians AND Israelis in creating a just and peaceful society that respects the rights of all the residents of this land, and offers us all a chance to pursue our happiness safely and securely.

Otherwise, you are choosing an arbitrary side in a contrived conflict that is fueled by propaganda, ignorance, and hate.

Furthermore.

Zionism does not demand uncritical and unwavering fealty to a policy or to a government or even to society itself. The biblical prophets railed against the corruption, injustice, and violence of their society in their day – in the name of Zion.

Zionism – consistently from the days of the Hebrew bible through the modern political era – does demand a commitment to justice, based on the recognition of the image of God in which every human being is created. Rebuilding Gaza and ending the military administration of civilian populations are both entirely consonant with that central demand of Zionism.

If you support Zionism, then you should logically support justice for Palestinians as an integral part of establishing Zion in justice.

If you support justice for Palestinians, then you should logically support Zionism not just as a historically necessary complement to that cause but as the very means to actualizing its success.

Nothing about this situation is zero-sum.

And finally.

I reiterate my invitation to all Israelis and Palestinians to join me in establishing a just and peaceful society for us all in this land which is our sacred heritage. Our ancestors shared a covenant, our fates are intertwined – come, let us reason together for the sake of our grandchildren.

We Are Guilty

All year long we avoid our shadow, we avert our gaze from the many ways in which it falls upon others and robs them of the light…

All year long we hide in the very tree we were warned against, we pretend to ourselves that our maker will not see us, does not want to see us, if we don’t want to be seen…

All year long we tell ourselves a story, a grand myth of our virtuous heroism and their vicious villainy, proclaimed on an empty stage to a crowd of none…

But there is freedom in admitting the truth.

“We are neither so brazen nor so stubborn as to say before you that we have not failed; but both we and our fathers –

We are guilty.
We betrayed.
We robbed.
We slandered.
We caused error –
And we caused injustice.
We acted maliciously.
We acted violently.
We dealt falsely.
We gave bad advice.
We misled.
We raged.
We mocked.
We rebelled.
We resented.
We lusted.
We over-indulged.
We erred.
We acted negligently.
We tormented.
We doubled-down.
We acted unjustly.
We corrupted.
We disgusted.
We strayed.
We oppressed.

We turned away from your instructions and your good laws, and it was not worth it – while you have been just in all that has happened to us; you have acted in truth and we caused injustice.

What can we say before you?

What story can we tell you?

You know everything – hidden and revealed.

. . .

And so may it be willed before you:

That you let go of all our failures.

That you overlook all of our mistakes.

That you forgive all of our negligence.

. . .

And may the words of my mouth be desired,

And the meditation of my heart be before you,

My lord –

My rock –

My liberator.”

The Ceasefire Plan

The Trump ceasefire plan does not seem substantially different from the Biden ceasefire plan.

The timetable for some things is a little faster, for other things a little slower. There is a stark cosmetic difference in the language.

But it seems to set out roughly the same basic points for both Israel and Hamas as the previous administration’s proposal.

🤷

There are definitely good, if vague, points set out in the plan.

But there are also some red flags:

I think setting up a Board of Peace headed by a corrupt authoritarian to rule Gaza via a puppet technocracy sounds shady.

I don’t trust the current US government.

And I’m left with a lot of questions about many of the points and how they will be implemented.

So I have my reservations about this ceasefire plan, like I did about the war itself; but if it brings about an end to the war, the elimination of Hamas, the return of the hostages, and the rebuilding of Gaza, then those will undeniably be good things.

American Amnesia

Evening Musing:

The American relationship with history is very peculiar.

American society insulates itself with a certain willful amnesia, an official disinterest in the critical study of the past.

People seem to prefer myth and legend over fact and evidence. The civil religion requires a certain uncritical ahistoricity. Skeptics are unpatriotic, revisionists are heretics.

And let’s be clear: that goes for American partisans of either flavor. Leftists and right-wingers alike seem conditioned by this peculiar relationship with history.

Jewish People as White

The racing of Jewish people as “white” has a lot to do with developments in American racial politics over the course of the 20th century and little to do with contemporary or historical Jewish people.

In actuality, Jewish people are of West Asian descent and have since absorbed the genes of other human communities on every continent except Antarctica, to the point where we can legitimately be described as transcending the Western social construct of “race” entirely.

By the same token, it should go without saying that assimilated Jewish individuals who identify as “white” should probably learn more about the Jewish community’s historical relationship to, and subjection to discrimination and even violence under, the social regime of “whiteness.”

Comey’s Regret

I wonder if James Comey regrets putting the investigation of Clinton’s email server in the national spotlight right before the 2016 election.

How Many New Years

Whew. Said the prayers. Blew the shophar. Ate the honey. Let my wife rest through the night.

I showed up, I did my part, I stood with every single being in creation and crowned my King.

Despite everything, Rosh Hashana was, thank God, a success in my little corner of the cosmos.

Barukh Hashem.

Mammash.

But.

As we started the month of Tishri, I opened up Isaiah for the next review. And I returned to the following verses:

“Your new moons and fixed seasons fill Me with loathing; they are become a burden to Me, I cannot endure them.

And when you lift up your hands, I will turn My eyes away from you; though you pray at length, I will not listen. Your hands are stained with crime—

Wash yourselves clean; put your evil doings away from My sight. Cease to do evil;

Learn to do good. Devote yourselves to justice; aid the wronged. Uphold the rights of the orphan; defend the cause of the widow.”

These verses made me think.

I thought of the attacks on farmers and shepherds in Yehuda and Shomeron.

I thought of the devastation in Gaza, excessive beyond the needs of self-defense and exploited for corrupt profit.

I thought of the hostages abandoned to Hamas, their families libeled as traitors for demanding accountability.

I thought of the widows and orphans of fallen soldiers and murdered civilians, sacrificed by career politicians clinging to power.

I thought of our society, built on holy ideals and ancient dreams, but that has become tolerant of too much violence against the vulnerable and too much injustice against the innocent.

How many new years will we celebrate while glibly justifying the ultimately unjustifiable?

How can we crown our King when we can not recognize his image and likeness?

What good are my prayers when both the Temple and Gaza lie in ruins?

Beloved, let us return to the covenant of our ancestors and the ways of our King.

We may have gone astray but all is far from lost.

There is still time for us to reconsider our path going forward.

This is the time.

“Come, let us reach an understanding, —says GOD. Be your sins like crimson, they can turn snow-white; be they red as dyed wool, they can become like fleece.”

OCD and the Days of Awe

Due to a mishap in my prescription fulfillment, this Rosh Hashana, I’ll be without my OCD medication for the first time since I started taking it.

For those who don’t live with OCD, all they know of it – all they see of it – are some odd behaviors and preferences, some rigidity in personal habits. Those outward signs seem bizarre but trivial, and the mental, emotional, and psychological backdrop and context to them is mysterious at best, ignored at worst, leaving only the visible tip of the iceberg.

For those of us who live with OCD, we know there’s so much more to it. The mental invasions and loops and ruts, the overwhelming pressure and anxiety and need, the emotional disruption and physical anguish, the isolation and the depression. The overly critical view of everything and the desperate search for control. Needing things to be even between right and left, or clean of contamination – that’s just a glimpse into the maddening world of OCD.

It’s definitely not my choice to enter a time fraught with so much legitimate and healthy anxiety and trepidation, with a brain wired for neurosis.

But that’s how my Creator intends for me to go through the sacred process this year. To stand before my King, holy and broken, ready to accept the guiding yoke of the Kingdom of Heaven. To hear in the shophar’s voice my own primal cry for release and redemption from my obsession with my failures.

And I’ve certainly done it before – faced this challenge without the help of medicine.

So

A) Wish me הצלחה success in my encounter with my King

B) In the spirit of sweetening judgment, if you know someone who displays signs of neurosis or even just rigidity, have grace and be charitable towards them – you don’t know what it’s like to stand in their shoes, especially at this time

C) If you suspect you may have OCD or another type of neurological misconfiguration / neurochemical imbalance and it’s adversely affecting your life, please talk with a psychiatrist about how medication may help you. Please. I know there’s tremendous social stigma in the West surrounding mental and emotional health, but you’re not alone and you deserve a better quality of life. And those close to you will appreciate it too. 😉

May we all be inscribed and sealed in the Book of Life ❤️